Casey was born in Colorado Springs, Colorado. He witnessed his brother A.J. Ager earn a lot of success in the radio industry and decided to go into the performance industry also. He attended Adams State College in Alamosa, CO, studying the theater arts. In the meantime Casey's brother AJ was forming Possessed Hand Productions which Casey quickly became a part of. The brothers wanted to form a company where AJ could write pieces and have a company of actors and actresses to count on to play certain roles. Casey has acted in almost all of the Possessed Hand Productions projects since 2001.
He is an avid softball player and singer. Cutting many CDs for a local fan base. He is a New York Mets fan and a huge Jerry Rice fan. In many of his performances he usually has a shirt or hat on for one of his favorite teams.