Normally This Weird (2009)

When two newlyweds start their lives together in a new town, little do they realize just how weird their neighbors are... The "Smiths" secretly practice dark magic, the Archevals (pronounced Ark-uh-vuhl, naturally) experiment with dangerous super-science, the enigmatic and eye-patched Swivey Dinkle lives his own brand of suburban adventure, all while FBI Agent Danford covertly monitors everything.