Still A Mystery (2018) | Full Cast

Benita Alexander-Noel

Narrator

Andrew Mcpherson

Narrator

Larry Mihlon

Self - Chief, Long Branch NJ Police Department (ret.)

Stacy Bridavsky

Self - Podcast Host

Selma Eikelenboom

Investigator

Ray Moore

Self - Holly's Father

April Moore

Self - Holly's Sister

Heidi Hemmat

Self - Reporter Fox31

Cassie Fambro

Self - Reporter NBC15 Mobile AL

Tim Ratcliff

Self - Sgt., Castle Rock CO Police Department

Etienne Maurice

Self - Lyric's Friend

Doug McHenry

Self - Lyric's Dad

April Eve Wiberg

Self - Founding Member, Stolen Sisters & Brothers

Briana Whitney

Self - Reporter, 3TV News

Rachelle Elsiufi

Self - CityNews

Max Mayes

Self - Private Investigator

Jonathan Arden

Self - Forensic Pathologist

Kelly Osborn

Self - Sheena's Mother

Todd Andreacchio

Self - Christian's Father

Kendall Herold

Self - WCPO News

Tina Barrett

Self - Markham Family Attorney

John Crews

Self - Jonathan's Father

Kiersten Bragg

Self - Kiera's Mother

Sherry Ballard

Self - Crystal's Mother

Tootsie Toccaro

Self - Amber's Mother

Katrin Steck

Self - Jennifer's Friend

Chris Thompson

Self - Christian's Uncle

Vance Patton

Self - Det., Indiana State Police

Toni Jacobs

Self - Keeshae's Mother

Cara Jorgensen

Self - Friend

Pam Dearwester

Self - Jason's Mother

Kelly Eastman

Self - Jason's Sister

Brendan Coffey

Self - Friend

Dara Riordan

Self - Jennifer's Friend

Ann Bowdan

Self - WKLY News

Jennifer Niswender

Self - Julia's Twin Sister

Pamela Crews

Self - Jonathan's Mom

Gary Shadie

Self - Det., Akron Ohio Police Department

Kris Bratten

Self - Jason's Mother-In-Law

Lee Williams

Former Police Office

Rick McCubbin

Self - Fmr. Chief, Bardstown KY Police Department

Kassie Coleman

Self - Disttrict Attorney, 10th Circuit Court

Stacey Talbot

Self - Inspector, Royal Canadian Mounted Police

Holly Moore

Self - APTN Investigates

Jevona Livingston

Self - Ketie's Mother

Mike Ballard

Self - Crystal's Uncle

Matt Hefner

Self - Det., Charlotte Mecklenburg NC Police Department - Cold Case Unit

Dave Morris

Self - Sheena's Father

David Markham

Self - Katelyn's Father

Tom Roby

Self - Family Spokesman

Jan Johnson

Self - Forensic Specialist

Rae Andreacchio

Self - Christian's Mother

Jay'Quann Banks

Self - Taylor's Brother

Emily Ramsey

Self - Jonathan's Friend

Toby Dagenhart

Self - Jennifer's News Director

Christian Crews

Self - Jonathan's Brother

Lacey Young

Self - Jason

Jonathan Carlson

Self - Investigative Journalist

Michael Clark

Self - Det., Bardstown KY Police Department

Paul Harrop

Self - Journalist

Jasmine Turner

Self - Reporter NBC12

Rebecca Ervin

Self - Sgt., Fairfield OH Police Department

Casey Ballard

Self - Crystal's Brother

Taylor Dial

Self - Christian's Friend

Fallon Glick

Self - Reporter, WDRB

Karin Johnson

Self - Reporter, WLWT

Sherry Abel

Self - Jennifer's Mother

Alexandra Elich

Self - Reporter, WCCB

Sheila Wysocki

Self - Private Investigator

Elfreda Tyler Anderson

Self - Keeshae's Aunt

Tim Dimoff

Self - Private Investigator

Maya McHenry

Self - Lyric's Sister

Christa Handford

Self - Jennifer's Sister

Kim Turnquist

Self - Julia's Mom

Chris Bragg

Self - Kiera's Father

Madison Turnquist

Self - Julia's Sister

Brooke Bryan

Self - Crystal's Sister

Stephanie Warsmith

Self - Akron Beach Journal Reporter

Janell Robinson

Self - Keeshae's Friend

Jessica Oh

Self - Reporter, WLKY TV News

Braydee Bragg

Self - Kiera's Sister

Becca Livingston

Self - Ketie's Sister

Salvatore Rastrelli

Self - Det., Martin County FL Sheriff's Office (ret.)

Tom Shaw

Self - Crew's Family Attorney

Carmilla Rucker

Self - Taylor's Mother

Edna Sims

Self - Family Spokesman

Michael Mooney

Self - Freelance Journalist

Sean Kipe

Host 'Fox Nation'

Gavin Fish

Self

Simone Jameson

Self (Reporter)