Director
Ben Steele
DIRECTOR
Simon Gilchrist
Stars (in credits order)
Joshua Vallum
Self
J. Drew Segadelli
Self - criminal defense attorney
Mary Hargon
Self - Sarah Adelia Graves' mother
Adrian Loya
Self - murder-accused
Destiny Allen
Self - friend of murder victim
Taylor Graves
Self - Sarah Adelia Graves' niece
Sandra Stasher
Self - deputy chief of Jackson City police department
Ben Brown
Self - George County sheriff's investigator
Bill Shields
Self - reporter, WBZ News
Brian Glenny
Self - 1st assistant district attorney, Cape & Islands District Attorney's Office
Margaret Baker
Self - reporter, The Sun Herald
James Bradfield
Self - James Craig Anderson's partner
Jacob Heller
Self - Adrian Loya's lifelong friend
Jimmie Adkins
Self - murder victim's neighbor
Cherie Rivera Wade
Self - Mississippi State assistant district attorney
Sam Sherman
Self - Sarah Adelia Graves' sister
Martin Kelly
Self - forensic psychiatrist
Jody E. Owens II
Self - managing attorney, Southern Poverty Law Center
Jameson Comey
Self - murder victim Lisa Trubnikova's neighbor
Anthony N. Lawrence III
Self - Mississippi State prosecutor
Donald Alway
Self - FBI special agent, Jackson City, Mississippi
Kelly Vallum
Self - Joshua Vallum's mother
Joshua Parson
Self - police officer, Bourne, Massachusetts
Bobby Vallum
Self - Joshua Vallum's father
Sarah Miles
Self - Sarah Adelia Graves' grandmother
Jay Perry
Self - police sergeant, Bourne, Massachusetts
Anna Trubnikova
Self - Lisa Trubnikova's wife
Henry T. Wingate
Self - district judge, Court for the Southern District of Mississippi
Jake Vallum
Self - Joshua Vallum's brother
Kayla Loar
Self - friend of Sarah Adelia Graves
John F. Doble
Self - police detective, Bourne, Massachusetts
William Zane
Self - forensic pathology specialist, Boston, Massachusetts
Thomas M. Fortner
Self - Sarah Adelia Graves' lawyer
Sarah Adelia Graves
Judith G. Edersheim
Self - assistant professor of psychiatry, Harvard Medical School
Tim Delap