Director
Bill Thomas
DIRECTOR
Nick Davies
Neil Rawles
Matthew Muskett
Ian Clark
Christopher Puttock
Tom Brisley
Stephen Oxenham
Kat Peschken
Lucie Richards
Jonathan Davenport
Adam Warner
Steve Baker
Lydia Delmonte
Phil Bowman
Kim Smith
Andrea Jones
Chris Roberts
Emily Renner Wallace
Elliot Goldner
Tom Lindley
Marios Hamboulides
Aminah Brunt
Jessica Burgess
Miriam Fitzgerald
Mik Bakalarz
Rachel Carmichael
Stars (in credits order)
Tom Streithorst
Narrator
Robert Firth
Grant Ross
Detective Juan
Mark Behan
Wiseguy
Adam Neill
James Kohnle
Steve Larter
Detective David Wheloth
Cassandra Celeste Smith
Girl outside of bar
Dominique Maher
Elizabeth Bennett
Ceridwen Morris
Carolyn Dawley
Nathan Roberts
Captain Ogden
Candice van Litsenborgh
Katrina Strickland
Anlezia Moné
Cassie Cotta
Daniel Lasker
Madison Holton
Laura Lake
Detective
Fayzal Haneker
John Parker
Cameron Butterwick
Nicholas Futo
Rob Whedbee
Self - Victim
Michael Warburton
Louis Masgay
Chris Wilson
Detective 2
Theo Devaney
Brian Trimble
Joe Gallina
Cop
Peter Brooke
Detective Rob Armstrong
Greg Canestrari
Head Detective Clarke Schwarzkopf
Dan Bradford
George Malliband
Matthew Brenher
Phil Solimene
Stewart Alexander
Max Jones
Eleanor Burke
Charla Mack
Jag Patel
Self - Actor
Conor Boru
Pat Kane
Katherine Ramsland
Self - Professor, Forensic Psychologist
Luke Ireland
Darren Mack
Louis B. Schlesinger
Self - Professor, Criminal Psychologist
Clark Schwartzkopf
Self - Detective, Phoenix Police Department
Carl Andersson
Daniel Bartelt
Victoria Campbell
Self - Crime Writer
Jel Djelal
Dominik Polifrone
Matthew David McCarthy
New Jersey Policeman
Erin Lampart
Michelle Archer
Laura Bartelt
Dominick Polifrone
Self
Marshall Griffin
John Chamberlain
Alan Cassidy
Shopper
Scott Haney
Ron Horton
Richard Thickens
Self - Detective, Hartford Police Department
Jason Wilson
Gary Smith
Self -Detective, New Jersey State Police
Sean D. Gaston
Christine Kuklinski
Self - Daughter
Randy Hausner
Self - Dale's Brother
Phoebe Ladenburg
Randi Trimble
Yara Caubet
Joy Blodgett
Nancy Chavez
Self - Randi's Mother
Mike Lazorcik
Rebekah Herzberg
Justin Mendez
Self - Tony Mendez's Son
David Conrad
Self - Brian's Friend
Alex Jones
Self - Janeen and Max's Son
Steven E. Pitt
Self - Forensic Psychiatrist
Wendy Keesey
Self - Brian's Mother
David Jenkins
Self - Det., Reno Police Department
Joel Clausing
Self - Detective, Washington County Sheriff's Office, WI
Paul Smith
Self - Lead Detective, New Jersey State Task Force
Buck Blodgett
Self - Jessie's Father
Dominic Harris
Self - Officer, Sarasota Police Department
Mark Phillips
Self - Charla's Boyfriend
Moriah Boehlen
Self - Soprano, Hartford Union High School
Soorya Townley
Self - Charla's Mother
Neil Hobbs
Det Ron Chalmers
Zak Jones
Bob Carroll
Self - State Prosecutor - New Jersey
Chandra Mayer
Self - Charla's Best Friend
Shanna Hourihan
Self - Assistant State Attorney
Skip Ebert
Self - District Attorney
Marilee Martinez
Self - Darren's cousin & employee
Ron Chalmers
Kathryn Debbage
Wendy Norris
Ian Nytes
Self - Jessie's Friend
Robert Armstrong
Self - Det., Sarasota Police Department
Ali Lanyon
Self - TV Reporter
Laura Reckart
Self - Prosecutor, Maricopa County
Katie Mayer
Self - Crime Reporter
Tyler Salzbrun
Self - Drummer, The Angry Pillows
Self - Family Friend
Elena Reid
Self - Professional Boxer
Bob Glasgow
Joan Mack
Self - Darren's Mother
Jessie McBride
Hollie Crisp
Alison Collyer
Kim Humphrey
Self - Commander, Phoenix Police
Scot Cooper
Det. Jason Mackie
Athena Strates
Tonya Beasley
Vere Tindale
Neal Williams
Shaleeni Ranchhod
Sargent Sandy
Robin Smith
Richard Beasley
Michael Kirch
Detective Darren Annis
Matthew Dylan Roberts
Billy Bear Slaughter
Self - Richard & Tina's Daughter
Leon Clingman
Michael Rafferty
Richard Wright-Firth
Kevin Dowling
Mario Ramirez
Heike Brunner
Laura Bowman
Joanne Brenizer
Self - Kevin's Ex-Wife
Tina Beasley
Self - Tonya's Mother
Rayna Funk
Self - Brogan's Half Sister
Scott Davis
Self - Survivor
Corrina Skorker
Self - Chrissy Billis's Daughter
Branagan Reiling
Self - Cindy's Niece
Teri Johnson
Self - Mike's Sister
Barry Bertolet
Self - Toni's Brother
Robert Boyle
Self - Prof., Dickinson College, PA
Linda's Yates
Self - Amber and Michelle's Mom
Rodney Baker
Self - Det., Darke County Sheriff's Department
Jason Mackie
Self - Det. Lt., Noble County IN Police Department
Grace Rishell
Self - Lynn's Sister-in-Law
Chris Rabe
Self - Cindy's Sister
Pam Helenek
Self - property owner of the car wreck site.
Steve Merrill
Self - Host of 'It's News to Us'
Freeda Burns
Self - Frank's Sister
Mike Hilley
Self - Frank and Marie's Son
Mark Wilson
Self - Detective, Albuquerque Police Department
Dameon Huffman
Self - Amber's Daughter
Michael MacKenzie
Brian Maass
Self - Investigative Journalist
Bob Bertolet
Self - Toni's Father
Amber Holscher
Self - Linda's Granddaughter
Melaney Ramirez
Travis Meyers
Self - Jack's Son
Shawn Trissel
Self - Sgt., Darke County Sheriff's Department
Cathy Nau
Self - Cindy's Daughter
Kim Hudson
Self - Linda's Daughter
Tammi Abbruscato
Self - Toni's Co-Worker
Mason Konrade
Amanda Yates
Self - Bob and Linda's Daughter
Steve Helenek
Self - property owner of car wreck site
Michelle Yates
Denise Bertone
Self - L.A. County Coroner Investigator
Lora Thomas
Self - Douglas County CO Coroner
Jan Williams
Self - Neal's Mother
Bill Morlin
Self - Journalist
Mark Whittaker
Wayne Manis
Self - FBI Special Agent (ret.)
Bertha Zaidle
Self - Corsicana Police Detective, ret.
Norman Brown
Self - FBI Agent
Kevin Leland
Self - Chrissy's Friend
Jack Howard
Self - Kiowa County Undersheriff, ret.
Tom Kelley
Todd Bertolet
Mike Stedham
Self - Radio Journalist
Darren Annis
Self - Det. Sgt., Vermont State Police
Hilton Pelser
Self - Jonathan Sanford
Liza Scholtz
Melinda Vargas
Nathan Lynn
Kenny Smith
Michael Bundred
Detective Randy Scott
Alex Anlos
Detective Hargett
Karolin Etzel
Marlisa Doubell
Clinic Manager
Lela Henke-Dobroth
Self - Chief Deputy District Attorney (ret.)
Gabriella Pinto
Diane Lafferty
Scott George
Charles Sennet
Randy Scott
Self - Insp., Oklahoma City Police Department (ret.)
Carolyn Benjamin
Self - Dennis' Girlfriend
Rowan Studti
Craig Thrift
Matthew Peterson
Chuck Sennet
Jody Ponsell
Self - Capt., Ware County GA Sheriff's Office (ret.)
Angela Horton
Self - Susan's Daughter
Radley Horwitz
Self - Donna & Lanny's Son
Shannon Rouse
Juanique Randall
Amy
Theresa Tortolana
Self - Beverly's Mother
Danielle Salmon
Samantha Wohlford
Don Foley
Self - Det., Dyer IN Police Department
Glenn Hopper
Self - Det., Butler County KS Sheriff's Office (ret.)
Chase Agulhas
Nathan Paet
Mike Sennett
Self - Liz & Charles' Son
Skip Young
Self Det., Ventura CA Police Department
Lemoyne Rhoades
Self - Donna's Friend
Terrie Hubbard
Angel Curry
Self - Terry's Sister
Debbie English
Self - Matthew's Mom
Amy Bensema
Self - Diane's Niece
Sean Conroy
Self - Det., Ventura CA Police Department (ret.)
Michael Gutierrez
Self - Punkie's Friend
Helene Underhay
Brenda Lafferty
Diane Strug
Self - Beverly's Sister
Veronica Paet
Self - Nathan Paet's Sister-in-Law
Paul Tippin
Self - Det., Los Angeles CA Police Department (ret.)
Self - Eric's Brother
Mike Shibley
Blanca Harrod
Self - Punkie's Mother
Larry English
Self - Debbie's Husband
Wes Lane
Self - Former Oklahoma County OK District Attorney
Michelle Fleck
Self - Chief Deputy District Attorney
Terri Kirby
Self - Joan's Best Friend
Kelly Herzet
Self - Sheriff, Butler County Kansas
Kim Sennett
Self - Mike's Wife
John Tortolana
Self - Beverly's Father
Bobby Tortolana
Self - Beverly's Brother
Randy Coffman
Debi Dawley
Self - Joan & Dennis' Daughter
Scott Bensema
Self - Amy's Husband
Tim Kent
Self - Author, 'Murder From the Pulpit'
Doug Jenkins
Self - Forensic Investigator (ret.)
Eric Paet
Self - Nathan Paet's Brother
Aleksandra Dimitrijevic
Self - Dep. Prosecuting Atty, Lake County IN
April Tatum
Self - Terry's Sisiter-In-Law
Chuck Sennett
Janice Allen
Cheryl Majchrowicz
Self - Beverly's Daughter
Trix Vivier
Rebecca Fenton
Lauren Steyn
Marie Strickland
Mark Elderkin
Don Hatfield
Genna Galloway
Misty Jones
Phaedra Bell
Self - Megan's Friend
Motsi Tekateka
Edwin Brock
McCracken Poston
Self - Teresa's Defense Attorney
Marco Mintaka
Detective Arthurs
John Wukie
Self - MD, Sandusky County OH Coroner
Bonnie White
Self - Jim's Co-Worker
Sandy Sulzman
Self - Alene Jenkins' Sister
Lya du Toit
Shannon Thurman
Self - Rachel's Friend
Derek Smith
Self - Special Prosecutor, Monroe County TN Court
Chris Watkins
Self - Lt., Peoria County IL Sheriff's Office
William Richard Grossman
Self - Sandy and Alene's Father
Megan Rochelle Jenkins
Self - George and Alene Jenkins Adopted Daughter
Caleb Hatfield
Self - Rachel's Brother
Mindie Lehman
Clint Brookshire
Self - Dep., Monroe County TN Sheriff's Office
Self - Rachel's Dad
Maureen Spaulding
Self - Beth's Mom
Jack Thorp
Terry Jensen
Self - San Diego County CA - D.A.'s Office (ret.)
Judy Lehman
George Samuel Jenkins
Self - Alene's Husband
Brandy Roach
Self - Beth's Friend
Lisa Elwell
Self - Doug's Sister
Ben Hatchett
Self - Marie's Husband
Karen Jefferson
Arthur - Arthur & Linda's Daughter
Evelyn Grossman
Self - Sandy and Alene's Mother
Douglas Bailey
Self - Doug's Son
Self - Lt., San Diego County CA Sheriff's Office
Jacob Strickland
Self - Katrina and Mike's Son
Daryl Spaulding
Self - Beth's Brother
Ricky Johnson
Self - Dep., White County GA Sheriff's Office (ret.)
Jason Kiddey
Self - Det., Fremont OH Police Department
Dave Hoyle
Self - Det., Peoria County IL Sheriff's Office
Nancy Kohnle
Self - Jim's Sister
Sheila Dockery
Self - Marie's Friend
Samantha Payne
Self - Arthur & Linda's Daughter
Carol Bailey
Alene Jenkins
Self - Sandy Sulzman's Sister
Linda Burney
Self - Arthur's Ex-Wife
Caleb Kohnle
Self - Jim and Teresa's Son
Meghan Oberholzer
Tracie Miles
Jacques Theron
Robert Propp
Dominique Mabille
Michelle Werner
Fil Waters
Self - Det., Houston TX Police Department
Harry Harrold
Detective Mark Motz
Matt Dellowe
Nick French
Kimberly Mullen
Self - Vivian's Sister
Georgia Cappleman
Jayson Arredondo
Self - Mark's Brother
Neola Mace
Self - Diana's Friend
Mary Prestigiacamo
Self - Missy's Friend
Philippa Berrington-Blew
Joy Sidwell
Mario Gallucci
Self - Attorney
Claudine Varnado
Self - Adrienne's Grandmother
Janice Ross
Self - Forensic Pathologist
John Mapes Iii
Self - Simeonette's Brother
Siteria Gregory
Self - Friend
Vincent Fontenot
Self - Adrienne's Stepbrother
Larry Foust
Self - Hutchinson KS Police Department (ret.)
Shannon Lovell
Self - Dep., Lexington County SC Sheriff's Office
John Lindsey
Self - Mark and Michelle's Friend
Hayley Warner
Self - Michelle's Daughter
Caroline Hecker
Self - Reporter
Martin Alfaro
Self - MSTR INV., Riverside County CA Sheriff's Central Homicide Unit
Chase Warner
Self - Michelle's First Husband
Gina Gannella
Self - Mark's Girlfriend
Stefanie Thornton
Self - Missy's Sister
Theresa Mapes
Self - Simeonette's Mom
Dustin Mouser
Self - Vivian's Brother-In-Law
Ashley Wehde
Self - Mona's Daughter
David Schillinger
Self - Steve's Friend
Barbara Thornton
Self - Missy's Mother
Nicole Persson
Self - Joy's Daughter
Adam Green
Self - Det. Trp., Michigan State Police
Ronnie Rudd
Self - Donnie Rudd's Twin-Brother
Benita Doria
Gina
Don Hyde Jr.
Self - Chief, Calera OK Police Department
Joel Silver
Self - Videographer
Dorian Holdren
LT. Josh Adams (Re-enactment)
Reanae Childers
Self - Agent, Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (ret.)
Jodi Breton
Self - Deputy D.A., San Diego County California
Bradley Patton
Olyn Sexton
Self - Lt., Lexington County SC Sheriff's Office
Ben Smith
Self - Sac County IA Attorney
Amanda Lee
Travis Couture-Lovelady
Self - Sandy's Nephew
Erikka Bueford
Self - Tracie's Friend
Edie Couture
Self - Sandy's Sister
Self - Steve's Nephew
Jason Newlin
Self - Inv., State Attorney's Office
Joshua Manjarrez
Self - Lead Inv., Riverside County CA Sheriff's Central Homicide Unit
Steve Gray
Self - Det., Lindon City UT Police Department
Tammy Arredondo
Self - Mark's Mom
Rosie Clayton-Leslie
Self - Steve's Sister
Donna Petit
Self - Michelle's Mom
Michael Arredondo
Graham Hockley
Self -
Jennifer Fontenot
Self - Adrienne's Best Friend
Jordan Lee
Self - Jessica's Son
Aleisha Magee
Self - Adrienne and Jamie's Daughter
Karista Van Nest
Self - Lindsey's Van Nest
Mona Wehde
Self - Dustin's Mom
Tracy Delatte
Self - Adrienne's Cousin
Erica Jane Mills
ACTOR
Ernie Underwood
Glory Dee
Self - Dianne's Daughter
David Chaffin
Self - Michelle Chaffin's Brother
Darbie Ernst
Self - Sgt., Carlsbad CA Police Department
Pat Douglas-Butler
Will Thompson
Self - Prosecutor, York County SC
Frank Liverani
Self - Simeonette's Uncle
Self - Mike Sidwell's Wife
Lori Hart
Jordan Engelhart
Self - Ofc., Saginaw MI Police Department
Tony Wienmuller
Steve Pilkington
Self - Lindsey's Father
John Mapes II
Self - Simeonette's Dad
Debbie Cothren
Self - Lindsey's Mom
Jessica Lee
Cindy Hart Mulligan
John Hart
Self - Dianne's Son
Nick Garcia
Crystal Airington
Self - Vivian's Friend
Briana Wehde
Timothy Chambers
Self - Former Prosecutor
Anabelle Dias
Aubree Barnes
Self - Mike's Daughter
Scott Stallman
Self - Det., Carlsbad CA Police Department
Jennifer Armour
Lisa Whedbee
Sophie-Louise Craig
Amber (2021)
Emma Burdon-Sutton
Jean Schwarzkopf
Jamie B. Chambers
Officer Bobkiewicz
James G. Nunn
Michael Frazier
Sherry Stone
Debra Spake Miller
Jon-Scott Clark
Huw Samuel
Joseph Futo
Amanda Bolin
Self - Prosecuting Attorney
Deborah Tracey
Gail
Alexander Bean
Christian 'Little Chris' Grissom
Keyon Pittman
Self - Avis' Boyfriend
Chris van Rensburg
Matthew Gretz
Lionel Strasky
Darrel Wold
Nasa Ohalete
Keonte Chavis
Bobby Windebank
Tony
Frank Dillard
Self - Det., Ridgeland MS Police Department
Ashlee Boyson
Self - Ashlee's Daughter
Michael Grande
Self - Det., Charlotte- Mecklenburg NC Police Department
Cindy Kirkpatrick
Self - Stephanie's Father
Jon Harmon
Self - Ashlee's Father
Nikisha Grissom
Self - Keonte's Mom
Kalee Karsten
Erica
Jarden Lunsford
Self - Det., St. Tammany Parish LA Sheriff's Office
Teage Corrigan
Self - Ashlee's Son
Darrell Wold Jr.
Charlene's Stepson
Joyce Whedbee
Self - Rob's Mother
Bostyn Corrigan
Jay Adair
Self - Lead Prosecutor
Neil Kirkpatrick
Darrell Wold Sr.
Self - Charlene's Husband
Jennifer Austin
Self - Assistant District Attorney, Cleveland County OK - District 21
Dan Stewart
Self - Det., Knox County TN Sheriff's Office (ret.)
Max Smith
Self - Chief A.D. A., Russell County Alabama
David Olson
Self - Julie's Boyfriend
Debra Banks
Self - Avis' Mother
Cindy Marange
Self - Julie's Mom
Josh Harmon
Self - Terri & Jon's Daughter
Glenda Hayden-Sharpe
Self - Mamie's Daughter
Dean Kirkpatrick
Self - Neil & Cindy's Son
Berle Stokes
Self - Lt., Meridian ID Police Department
Bobby Marange
Self - Julie's Father
Charlene Schwarzkopf
Self - Richard's Wife
Jim Mikla
Self - Inv., St. Croix WI County Sheriff's Office
Nicola Lugosch
Self - Stephanie's Friend
Fredreana Banks Rowster
Self - Avis' Sister
Laetitia Campbell
Self - Det., Meridian ID Police Department
Joey Ferraro
Self - Brandon's Friend
Ricardo Thomas
Self - Mamie's Grandson
John Neal
Self - Lt., Ridgeland MS Police Department
Larry Rhodes
Self - Sheriff, Garvin County OK (ret.)
Karissa Hayden
Self - Mamie's Granddaughter
Mark Bateman
Detective William Ostendorf
Mckenna Anderson
Leslie Simonian
Self - Kira's Sister
Harold Smith
Self - Lt., Russell County AL Sheriff's Office
Heath Taylor
Self - Sheriff, Russell County Alabama
Richard Schwarzkopf
Self - Jean's Son
J. Michael Shea
Self - Joseph's Defense Attorney
Cyndi Wear
Self - Brandon's Mom
Courtney Wray-Harmon
Self - Keonte's Second Cousin
Ann Kjos
Self - Det., Minneapolis MN Police Department
Garrett Wear
Self - Brandon's Brother
Frank Miskov
Self - Emory Sr.'s Cousin
Tammy Saunders
Self - 911 Supervisor, Catabwa County NC Sheriff's Office
Lara Simonian
Abby Harmon
Self - Terry & Jon's Son
Kerry Penley
Self - Sgt., Catabwa County NC Sheriff's Office
Erica Rikard
Self - Tabatha's Sister
Debbie Miller
Self - Tabetha and Erica's Mother
William Ostendorf
Self - Det., St. Louis County MO Police Department
Dan Miller
Self - Tabatha's Stepfather
Troy Hayden
Clequot
Self - Keonte's Uncle
Jean Spies
Logan Reese
Titus Corrigan
Self Ashlee's Son
Terri Harmon
Self - Ashlee's Mother
Cat Kiiza
Jill Zeringue
Self - Julie's Sister
Kari Schmitz
Self - Ofc., Minneapolis MN Police Department
Daniel Galati
Self - Emory Jr.'s Friend
Michael Hoyle
Self - Cpl., Catabwa County NC Sheriff's Office
Belinda Thomas-McCrae
Jess Harmon
Self - Terri & Jon's Son
Anthony Chavis
Self - Keonte's Dad
Greg Mashburn
Self - District Attorney, Cleveland County OK - District 21
Betty Miskov
Dean Fayerweather
Bailey Corrigan
Renee Schwarzkopf
Self - Jean's Daughter
Brian Kirkpatrick
Self - Stephanie's Cousin
Aaron Turk
Self - Lt., Catabwa County NC Sheriff's Office
Grant Kinnamon
Self - Dep., Chisago WI County Sheriff's Office
Alli Harmon
Kelly Rieker
Self - Emmett's Co-Worker
Bob Schwarzkopf
Jim Sessa
Self - Det., Pasco County FL Sheriff's Office
Paul Poulton
Self - Lt., Missouri City TX Police Department
Jacques Adriaanse
Jeffrey Scott
Bianca Bosch
Ashley Scott
Breanna Edelstein
Ramona Gomez
Self - Michelle's Mother
Bryan Davidson
Self - Wendi's Son
Josh Davidson
James Dousay
Self - Det., Harris County TX Sheriff's Department
Jeremy Taylor
Self - LaTonya's Son
LaTonya Taylor
Sandi Holmes
Self - Wendi's Sister
Marktonio Royster
Self - LaTonya's Stepbrother
Sylvester Taylor II
Self - LaTonya's Brother
Juan Viramontes
Self - Det., Harris County TX Sheriff's Office
Krystle Limon
Self - Michelle's Friend
Stacy Coletti
Self - Wendi's Cousin
Jason Walker
Self - Wake County NC District Attorney,
Larry Lira
Self - Michelle's Father
Wendy Mahoney Bean
Nicole Gomez
Self - Michelle's Sister
Van Pierre
Albert Pacheco
Melanie Palmer
Ruth Masgayuncredited
James Mitchell
Guitaristuncredited
Victor Grondel
Mike Snyderuncredited